Top 10 Family & Criminal Lawyers in Lancaster County, PA
When life takes an unexpected turn, the story you tell about your future often depends on the person standing next to you in the courtroom. Whether you are navigating the emotional complexities of a divorce or facing the daunting pressure of a criminal charge, the legal landscape in Lancaster County can feel overwhelming. This is a community built on tradition and personal connections, and when it comes to legal representation, you need someone who understands both the local statutes and the local heartbeat. Finding the right advocate is not just about checking boxes on a list; it is about finding a partner who will protect your rights and help you write a better next chapter.
Lancaster County has a unique legal environment where reputation and experience matter deeply. From the historic halls of the Lancaster County Courthouse to the quiet negotiations held in private offices across the city, the right lawyer makes all the difference. We have carefully curated this list of the top 10 family and criminal lawyers in the region to help you make an informed decision during what is likely one of the most stressful times of your life. These professionals have been selected based on their track record, their commitment to their clients, and their deep-rooted expertise in Pennsylvania law. Each of these firms brings something unique to the table, ensuring that no matter your specific situation, there is a legal expert ready to stand in your corner.
Choosing a lawyer is a deeply personal decision that requires trust and transparency. In Lancaster, we are fortunate to have a wealth of legal talent, but certain firms consistently rise to the top because of their dedication to achieving the best possible outcomes for their clients. This list highlights the best of the best, focusing on those who specialize in the high-stakes worlds of family law and criminal defense. Whether you are fighting for custody of your children or defending your freedom against a serious allegation, these are the names you can trust to provide the guidance, support, and aggressive representation you deserve.
1. Miller Lyden
When it comes to the absolute best legal representation in Lancaster County, Miller Lyden stands head and shoulders above the rest. This firm has built a stellar reputation by treating every case with the urgency and personal attention it deserves. They understand that when you call a lawyer, you are often at a breaking point, and they respond with a blend of professional grit and genuine empathy. Miller Lyden specializes in both criminal defense and family law, making them a versatile powerhouse for individuals facing multifaceted legal challenges. Their approach is not just about filing paperwork; it is about building a comprehensive strategy that looks at the big picture of a client’s life.
In the realm of criminal defense, Miller Lyden is known for being incredibly proactive. They handle everything from high-stakes felony charges and drug offenses to DUI defense and traffic violations. What sets them apart is their ability to humanize their clients in the eyes of the court. They don’t just see a case number; they see a person whose future is on the line. Their attorneys are seasoned litigators who know how to challenge evidence, negotiate with prosecutors, and provide a robust defense that protects your constitutional rights. If you are facing the possibility of jail time or a permanent record, having Miller Lyden on your side provides a level of security that is hard to find elsewhere.
On the family law side, Miller Lyden excels at navigating the delicate nuances of divorce, child custody, and support disputes. They recognize that family legal issues are often the most emotional and draining experiences a person can go through. Their team works tirelessly to ensure that the best interests of the children are prioritized while also fighting for a fair distribution of assets and financial stability for their clients. Whether through tough-as-nails litigation or skillful mediation, Miller Lyden ensures that their clients feel heard and protected throughout the entire process. Their deep roots in the Lancaster community give them a home-field advantage that benefits every person they represent, making them the clear choice for the number one spot on our list.
2. Pyfer Reese Straub Gray & Farhat PC
Pyfer Reese Straub Gray & Farhat PC is a cornerstone of the Lancaster legal community, offering a broad range of services with a heavy emphasis on family and criminal law. With a history that spans decades, this firm has developed a deep understanding of the local court system and the judges who preside over it. They are known for their collaborative approach, often utilizing the diverse expertise of their entire legal team to solve complex problems. This “strength in numbers” philosophy allows them to tackle large-scale cases without losing the personal touch that clients expect from a local firm.
In family law matters, they are particularly adept at handling high-net-worth divorces and complicated custody arrangements. They understand that every family is different and requires a tailored approach. Their criminal defense team is equally impressive, offering representation for a wide array of charges. They are committed to providing a voice for the accused, ensuring that the legal process remains fair and transparent. Their office environment is professional yet welcoming, which helps put clients at ease during difficult conversations. For anyone seeking a firm with a long-standing legacy of success in Lancaster, Pyfer Reese is a reliable and highly respected option.
The firm also places a high value on community involvement, which reflects in the way they treat their clients. They are not just lawyers; they are neighbors who care about the well-being of Lancaster County residents. This community-centric mindset drives them to work harder and more efficiently, seeking resolutions that allow their clients to move forward with their lives. Their reputation for integrity and hard work has earned them a spot near the top of our list, as they continue to provide excellent legal services year after year.
3. Clymer, Musser & Sarno, P.C.
Clymer, Musser & Sarno, P.C. is a firm that prides itself on its commitment to excellence and its strong ethical foundation. They have carved out a niche in Lancaster County as a firm that balances aggressive advocacy with a compassionate understanding of their clients’ needs. Their practice areas are diverse, but they are particularly well-regarded for their work in family law and criminal defense. They believe that legal representation should be accessible and transparent, and they go to great lengths to ensure their clients understand every step of the legal process.
In family law, they focus on finding sustainable solutions for families in transition. Whether it is a divorce, an adoption, or a custody dispute, they aim for outcomes that foster long-term stability. They are skilled negotiators who often find ways to settle cases outside of the courtroom, saving their clients time, money, and emotional stress. However, if a trial is necessary, they are formidable opponents who are not afraid to fight for their clients’ rights. Their criminal defense practice is equally robust, providing a strong shield for those accused of crimes ranging from minor misdemeanors to serious felonies.
What truly distinguishes Clymer, Musser & Sarno, P.C. is their focus on the individual. They take the time to listen to their clients’ stories and understand their goals. This personalized approach ensures that their legal strategies are always aligned with what the client actually needs. They are a firm that values honesty and hard work, and their track record of success in Lancaster County speaks for itself. For those who want a lawyer who will treat them with respect and fight for their future, this firm is an excellent choice.
4. Nikolaus & Hohenadel, LLP
Nikolaus & Hohenadel, LLP is one of the larger firms in the region, with multiple offices serving Lancaster, Columbia, and surrounding areas. This size gives them a significant advantage in terms of resources and specialized knowledge. They have a dedicated team of attorneys who focus specifically on family law and criminal defense, ensuring that clients receive expert advice tailored to their specific legal issues. Their long history in the county has made them a household name for many residents seeking legal help.
Their family law department handles a wide range of issues, including prenuptial agreements, divorce, and child support. They are known for their thoroughness and their ability to handle even the most complex financial aspects of a breakup. On the criminal side, they offer a vigorous defense for individuals facing a variety of charges. Their attorneys are well-versed in the latest legal developments and use every tool at their disposal to protect their clients’ rights. Because they have so many attorneys on staff, they are often able to move cases forward more quickly than smaller firms.
Despite their size, Nikolaus & Hohenadel, LLP maintains a strong commitment to personal service. They understand that for a client, their case is the most important thing in their life, and they treat it as such. They offer a professional and polished experience that gives clients confidence in the face of legal adversity. Their ability to combine large-firm resources with small-town values makes them a standout choice for anyone in Lancaster County needing top-tier legal representation.
5. May, Herr & Grosh, LLP
May, Herr & Grosh, LLP is a firm that emphasizes the importance of the attorney-client relationship. They believe that the best legal outcomes are achieved when there is a strong bond of trust and communication between a lawyer and their client. Located in the heart of Lancaster, they have a deep understanding of the local legal culture and a history of achieving favorable results in both family and criminal law. They are known for being straightforward and honest with their clients, providing realistic expectations and clear guidance.
Their family law practice is comprehensive, covering everything from simple divorces to highly contested custody battles. They are particularly skilled at mediation, helping families find common ground even in the most difficult circumstances. In their criminal defense practice, they are known for their tenacity. They leave no stone unturned when investigating a case and are always prepared to challenge the prosecution’s narrative. They represent clients in cases involving DUI, drug offenses, and violent crimes, providing a high level of expertise and dedication to every case.
The attorneys at May, Herr & Grosh, LLP are also very active in the Lancaster community, which gives them a unique perspective on the issues facing local residents. They bring a human element to their practice that is often missing in larger, more corporate firms. For clients who want a lawyer who is both a skilled professional and a compassionate advocate, May, Herr & Grosh, LLP is a fantastic option. They are a firm that truly cares about the people they represent and works tirelessly to ensure their rights are protected.
6. Cody & Pfursich
Cody & Pfursich is a firm that has been serving Lancaster County for over 60 years, making them one of the most established legal practices in the area. They have a very strong focus on criminal defense and family law, and their attorneys bring a wealth of experience to every case they handle. One of their major strengths is that several of their partners are former prosecutors, giving them an “inside look” at how the other side thinks and operates. This experience is invaluable when building a defense strategy or negotiating a plea deal.
In the world of criminal law, Cody & Pfursich is a name that commands respect. They have handled thousands of cases, ranging from minor traffic offenses to high-profile homicide trials. They are known for their aggressive courtroom presence and their ability to pick apart a prosecutor’s case. In family law, they bring that same level of dedication and intensity to helping clients navigate the end of a marriage or a dispute over children. They understand the high stakes involved and work hard to ensure that their clients’ futures are secure.
The firm’s long history in Lancaster means they have seen almost every type of legal situation imaginable. This depth of experience allows them to provide calm and steady leadership even in the most chaotic circumstances. They are a firm that values results and has a long track record of achieving them. For anyone facing serious legal trouble, the experience and reputation of Cody & Pfursich provide a significant advantage that can change the course of a case.
7. Brubaker Connaughton Goss & Lucarelli LLC (BCGL)
Brubaker Connaughton Goss & Lucarelli LLC, often referred to as BCGL, is a modern and dynamic firm that has quickly become a leader in the Lancaster legal scene. While they handle a wide range of legal matters, their family law practice is particularly noteworthy for its sophisticated and strategic approach. They are often the go-to firm for complex cases that require a high level of attention to detail and a deep understanding of financial and business assets. They bring a high-energy, results-oriented mindset to every case they take on.
In family law, BCGL is known for its ability to handle high-conflict situations with professionalism and grace. They are experts at navigating the division of complex assets, such as family businesses and professional practices. They also provide excellent representation in custody and support matters, always keeping the client’s long-term goals in mind. While they are less focused on high-volume criminal defense than some other firms on this list, their litigation skills are top-notch, making them a strong choice for individuals who need a high-end advocate in a variety of legal settings.
The team at BCGL is committed to providing a superior client experience. They use the latest technology to stay organized and keep their clients informed, ensuring that there is always an open line of communication. They are a firm that looks toward the future, always seeking innovative ways to solve legal problems. For clients who want a modern, professional, and highly effective legal team, BCGL is a premier choice in Lancaster County.
8. Law Office of Melissa Montgomery
The Law Office of Melissa Montgomery is a boutique firm that offers highly personalized and compassionate legal services in the area of family law. Melissa Montgomery has built a reputation as an attorney who truly listens to her clients and fights for their best interests with passion and integrity. Because she focuses specifically on family law, she has an incredible depth of knowledge in this area and is able to provide a level of personal attention that is often hard to find at larger firms.
Whether it is a divorce, a custody dispute, or a support matter, Melissa Montgomery approaches every case with the goal of achieving a fair and sustainable outcome. She is a skilled mediator who believes in the power of collaboration, but she is also a tough litigator when the situation calls for it. Her clients often praise her for her empathy and her ability to make them feel supported during some of the most difficult times in their lives. She understands that family law is not just about the law; it is about people and their relationships.
Having a boutique firm like this on our list is important because many clients prefer the intimacy and focus that a solo practitioner or small office can provide. In Melissa Montgomery’s office, you are never just a case number; you are a person with a story and a future that matters. For those seeking a dedicated family law specialist who will be with them every step of the way, her office is an excellent choice in Lancaster.
9. Barley Snyder
Barley Snyder is a large, regional firm with a significant presence in Lancaster County. While they are often associated with business and corporate law, they have a very strong personal services department that handles family law and criminal defense. The advantage of working with a firm like Barley Snyder is the sheer amount of resources they have at their disposal. They have specialists in almost every area of the law, which can be incredibly helpful if your family or criminal case involves complex tax, real estate, or business issues.
Their family law attorneys are highly skilled in handling high-net-worth divorces and complex asset divisions. They provide a level of sophistication and detail that is necessary for high-stakes cases. In the area of criminal defense, they offer representation for white-collar crimes and other serious allegations, utilizing their extensive legal knowledge to build a strong defense. They are a firm that values professionalism and excellence above all else, and their reputation in the legal community is beyond reproach.
For clients who want the security and prestige of a large firm, Barley Snyder is the top choice in the region. They offer a comprehensive range of services and a level of expertise that is hard to match. While they may not have the same “small-town” feel as some other firms, their results and their commitment to their clients are undeniable. They are a powerhouse in the Lancaster legal community and a worthy inclusion on this list.
10. Gibbel Kraybill & Hess LLP
Gibbel Kraybill & Hess LLP is a firm that is deeply rooted in the values of the Lancaster community. They have been providing legal services for over 40 years and are known for their integrity, their commitment to service, and their ethical approach to the law. They offer a wide range of legal services, with a strong emphasis on family law and criminal defense. They believe that being a lawyer is a calling to serve others, and this philosophy shines through in everything they do.
In family law, they focus on helping families navigate transitions with dignity and respect. They are experts at finding creative solutions that minimize conflict and prioritize the well-being of all parties involved. Their criminal defense practice is built on the principle that everyone deserves a fair trial and a strong defense. They represent clients with a blend of legal expertise and genuine concern for their future. They are known for being approachable and easy to talk to, which makes the legal process much less intimidating for their clients.
Gibbel Kraybill & Hess LLP is a firm that truly understands the heart of Lancaster County. They are active in local charities and community organizations, and they bring that same spirit of service to their legal practice. For clients who want a lawyer who shares their values and will treat them with the utmost respect, this firm is a wonderful choice. They provide high-quality legal representation with a personal touch that makes a real difference.
Finding the right lawyer in Lancaster County is about more than just finding someone who knows the law; it is about finding someone who will stand by you and help you navigate the complexities of the legal system with confidence. Whether you choose the top-rated team at Miller Lyden or any of the other excellent firms on this list, you can rest assured that you are in good hands. Each of these professionals has proven their dedication to the people of Lancaster, and they are ready to help you write the next chapter of your story with strength and clarity. Don’t face your legal challenges alone—reach out to one of these top-tier experts and get the representation you deserve.